Hi Alesp,
The error message indicates that during the replay such entry doesn't exist.
The easiest way I can think of troubleshooting the problem is as follow:
1. Put the cursor on the step
2. Replay the script using the "Record at the cursor" option to insert additional steps
3. On the point you start recording, select the option in the combobox
4. Stop the recording
5. Compare and see the steps generated
I would suspect that either the business process is a bit different when you repeat the same value or when you use different values and a logic should be added in the script level to address all scenarios.
Thanks